Pediatric Fractures: Does Vitamin D Play a Role?

Background: Vitamin D (25-OHD) deficiency and insufficiency are reported in about half of all children. The literature on low 25-OHD and pediatric fracture risk presents inconsistent results. This study evaluates the association between pediatric fractures and 25-OHD, parathyroid hormone (PTH), and calcium. Methods: This is a prospective case-control study in 2 urban pediatric emergency departments (2014-2017). Patients aged 1 to 17 requiring intravenous access were enrolled. Demographics, nutrition, and activity information were recorded and levels of 25-OHD, calcium, and PTH were measured. Results: Two hundred forty-five subjects were enrolled: 123 fractures and 122 controls. Overall, the mean 25-OHD level was 23 ng/mL±8.5: 52 (21%) of patients were 25-OHD sufficient; 193 (79%) were not. Ninety-six percent of patients with lower extremity fractures had low 25-OHD versus 77% of patients with upper extremity fractures (P=0.024). The fracture cohort was younger (P=0.002), included more males (P=0.020), and spent more time playing outdoor sports (P=0.011) than the control cohort. The 25-OHD level (fracture 22.8 ng/mL±7.6 vs. nonfracture 23.5 ng/mL±9.3, P=0.494) and median calcium level (fracture 9.8 mg/dL vs. nonfracture 10.0 mg/dL, P=0.054) were similar between cohorts. The median PTH level was higher in the fracture than the control cohort (33 vs. 24.5 pg/mL; P<0.0005); PTH was elevated to hyperparathyroidism (>65 pg/mL) in 13% of fractures and 2% of controls (P=0.006). Matched subgroup analysis of 81 fracture patients and 81 controls by age, gender, and race showed that PTH was the only variable independently associated with increased odds of fracture (odds ratio=1.10, 95% CI, 1.01-1.19, P=0.021) in a model adjusted for vitamin D sufficiency and time spent playing outdoor sports. Conclusions: Low 25-OHD is common in children with fractures but we found no difference in 25-OHD levels between fracture and nonfracture cohorts. This research can impact evidence-based guidelines on vitamin D level screening and/or supplementation after fracture. Level of Evidence: Diagnostic level IV - case-control study.