Subintimal angioplasty is superior to SilverHawk atherectomy for the treatment of occlusive lesions of the lower extremities

Purpose: To evaluate the outcomes of atherectomy versus subintimal angioplasty (SIA) in patients with lower extremity arterial occlusive disease. Methods: From September 2005 through July 2006, 27 patients (17 women; mean age 65 years, range 37-85) underwent atherectomy of 46 lesions (11 TASC C/D occlusions) with the SilverHawk device. Results were compared to 67 patients (34 men; mean age 69 years, range 46-92) undergoing SIA for 67 lower extremity arterial occlusions from July 1999 through June 2004. Results: Technical success in the atherectomy cohort was 100%. In the 11 patients with occlusions, symptoms improved in 10 and worsened in 1, but 9 (82.0%) of the 11 patients required reintervention, and 8 (72.7%) patients with occlusive lesions re-occluded. Endovascular reintervention was required to maintain primary patency in only 2 (12.5%) of 16 patients treated for stenotic lesions. At 1 year, the assisted primary patency was 37.7% in the atherectomy group. In the 11 patients with occlusive lesions, the patency rates were 36.8% and 12.3% at 6 and 9 months, respectively, versus 100% and 83.3% at the same time intervals in patients with stenotic lesions. SIA was technically successful in 56 (83.6%) of 67 occlusions. The assisted primary patency and limb salvage rates of the entire group (intention-to-treat) at 12 and 24 months were 59.2% and 45.0%, respectively, while the assisted primary patency of the 56 technically successful SIAs at 12 and 24 months were 70.7% and 53.8%, respectively. Limb salvage for the entire group (intention-to-treat) was 90.6% and 87.9% at 12 and 24 months, respectively. Conclusion: Atherectomy may yield acceptable primary patency and limb salvage in patients with stenotic lesions. Many of the patients treated for occlusive lesions require reintervention. Based on patency and limb salvage, SIA appears superior to atherectomy for the treatment of lower extremity occlusive disease.